Subject: [FFML] Re: [Fanfic][R1/2] I'm a Boy Chapter 1
From: Colleen Leah Morgan
Date: 2/4/2000, 11:27 AM
To: Jamie and Bridget Wilde
CC: ffml@fanfic.com


On Thu, 3 Feb 2000, Jamie and Bridget Wilde wrote:

The inspiration for this is, as might be guessed, the classic Who song;
however, it has little or nothing to do with the songfic for the same
song that was posted some time ago, and is also unrelated to the recent
fic "I'm a Guy."

I really really liked this story! It's made me smile more than almost any
other in recent memory. 

Comments and criticism, public and private, are most welcome.

Just a very few things, and mostly praise...

     "I must go," he declared sonorously, keeping his face stoic.  "I 
have neglected my art for far too long, lain at ease in the soft arms 
of domesticity, pampered into weakness and dissolution.  Such is not 
the way of the warrior."  He turned his profile to her, gazing into 
the endless night, just as the samurai on that night's TV drama had 
done.  "I must go on this training journey, for the sake of my art... 
and my soul."

Just lone wolf without the cub, hmm? :)

     "Yes, your duty."  He stepped forward again to lay a bracing hand 
on her shoulder.  "You must raise our children to be fine young ladies 
- indeed, women among women."
     "Women among women..." Her voice was hushed, hands clasped before 
her raptly; he could practically see the stars in her eyes.

And here's where it happens. Nodoka is so literal! But I can really see it
for her character.

     "I vow it, on my life and the lives of my children.  Women among 
women they shall be - or die."
     Deep within her, there was a faint stirring, as if in protest - 
but it was yet too faint for her to sense, barely a ripple in the 
ocean, and it would be another month before Nodoka realized that her 
vow had been spoken not for three children, but for four.

Poor Ranma. Always cursed one way or another.

What made it worse was that Akane knew that these 
same rude, insulting boys would do almost anything to catch even a 
glimpse of one of the girls they derided in the locker room, would 
practically faint if one of them actually agreed to a date.  Utterly 
pathetic.

Very astute. :)

     Ranko looked up in surprise.  "You mean martial arts?"  Her eyes 
were wide with shock, and really quite lovely.  Her face matched her 
build, slightly wider than was comfortable, but not unattractive.

Ranma the bishounen. I can and can't see it.

     "I... I just can't."  Ranko busied herself cleaning up the 
remains of her lunch, packing everything neatly into her Hello Kitty 
lunchbag.

Yay, Hello Kitty! Poor Ranma, a new reason to hate cats. :) There's
actually a very interesting article about the submissiveness inherent in
Hello Kitty and some other Sanrio characters, good reading.

The next three girls were variations on the theme, though 
obviously in the first bloom of youth, their hairstyles and kimono 
less severe in style.  They sipped from Kasumi's best teacups with 
unconscious grace, their attention focused on the adults at the head 
of the table.

Need a tab for this paragraph,

	"Indeed."  Mrs. Saotome's voice was like a viola, sweet and low 
and clear.  "Well, as I mentioned earlier, my husband has been gone on 
a training trip for some time now."

Beautiful detail work, this scene is really alive.

      "Now, Akane, please sit down.  You're disturbing our guests."  
Akane realized that the Saotome clan was indeed staring at her, the 
mother with a tiny frown of disapproval, the three older sisters with 
identical looks of polite curiosity, and Ranko with a peculiarly 
fearful fascination.

Akane, too genki for the sedate Saotome women, this is just too funny.

	"Really?"  Ranko twitched the hem of her kimono to cover her now-
somewhat-dusty _tabi_ socks.  "I think the Saotomes used to be really 
great, too.  I suppose we still are, if you count Father.  But we 
don't have a dojo."

Nice detail on the tabi. It's a little redundant, but good to explain to
general audiences.

	"You'd think you'd never had sukiyaki before," Akane teased as 
she followed them into the hall.
	Ranko's back stiffened visibly.  "Of... of course I've eaten 
sukiyaki before.  We have sukiyaki all the time at my house. Two or 
three times a week, in fact."

I like this, still flashes of the Ranma pride and personality.

	There was a note waiting for her the next morning when she went 
to change her shoes, pink Hello Kitty stationery sealed with a sticker 
that looked like a fishcake; Akane's name was written on it in purple 
ink, in rounded, bubbly script.  

Wow, perfect! You even got the girly script detail, color me very very
impressed.

      "Hey, what are you doing?"  Oh no, Ranko was one of those girls 
who liked other girls, this was all some ploy to get to Akane... "Stop 
that!"  Akane made a grab for Ranko's hands.

Well, in a way... :)

      "You will?  Oh, Akane!  I'm so glad you're a tomboy!"  Ranko 
bounced with glee in a most un-boylike way, clapping his hands 
together.  
      "Gee, thanks... I think."

Heh. I'm very interested in more of this, though it could almost stand
alone with all the sheer possibilities it presents. It was light and
serious at the same time, it actually kind of reminds me of Kodomo no
Omocha for some reason. Anyway, thank you very much for the read!

Colleen
--
One more stitch in one more place.



-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'