Subject: [FFML] Re: [fanfic][Utena] Ma Vie et Roses #5
From: Scott Jamison
Date: 11/18/2000, 8:28 PM
To: Alan Harnum , ffml@fanfic.com, zazyg@io.com



--- Alan Harnum <harnums@thekeep.org> wrote:

You know what would really make this story better?  If it came out

faster.  ^_^



I think so too.



I don't like the very concept behind SIs.  I read fanfiction

because I'm 

interested

in reading about the characters of the series.



I agree.  While sometimes stories that focus on new characters are

well done, when the label is from a show I recognize, I'm reading it

for the characters I recognize and like....]





But I do like this story; its excellence, and general exception

from other 

SIs, is

how it uses the SI format to hold up the mirror of an outsider's 

perspective to the

series cast.  So far, it's as much or more about them (through

Skyler's eyes)

as it is about Skyler.  The Utena characters are all beautifully

written, 

and Skyler

isn't particularly annoying, as SIs go.  I realize this is

something of a 

backhanded

compliment, but...



    The "no foreknowledge" thing helps there, I hope.  And we do try

to be honest about Skyler's flaws as well as his good points.



It's good to see that the story is beginning to diverge more

significantly from

Utena canon, and we're beginning to see hints (in the sequence in

the

library with Skyler and Juri) of just what he might have been

brought here to

do.  This chapter also seemed to have less of Skyler brooding by

himself

(which is something that I didn't like in previous parts) and more

of Skyler

interacting with the cast (which is what I like to see).



     Skyler's naturally introspective (one of the reasons he's an

otaku), but he *is* trying to be friendlier and actually talk to

people....



An excellent job all around.  I just wish that the story would come

out faster;

if you're going to end on cliffhangers like this one, it's not fair

to make 

us wait

so many months.  :)



     We'll see what we can do....Tune in next time, as Nanami watches

and takes notes during a showing of "Don't Leave Me, Daisy!"





SKJAM!



__________________________________________________

Do You Yahoo!?

Yahoo! Calendar - Get organized for the holidays!

http://calendar.yahoo.com/





-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'