Subject: [FFML] Re: [fanfic][Ranma]Bedlam Fire Chapter 3
From: allyn yonge
Date: 12/15/2000, 1:00 PM
To: Gary Kleppe , ffml@fanfic.com

Hi,

Once again, many thanks for taking the time

to read and C&C.



Comments on comments @@

--- Gary Kleppe <kleppe@mediaone.net> wrote:

Allyn Yonge <ayonge@yahoo.com> wrote:



<SNIP>



"Listen, you."



stand out in horrid contrast. "I know you did

something to my

Ran-chan.  Ranma honey wouldn't have cut class

unless you

did something to him!"



Actually, in "Beat Up the Principal" Ukyo and Akane

caught Ranma cutting class

with Hinako; so if Ukyo really thinks this, her

memory's being rather selective.

(Which is certainly possible, considering who we're

talking about.)



@@Selective memory. I was particularly thinking

about the Weakness Moxibustion story where

she fantasizes about what a happy life she and 

weak-Ranma will lead>> She cooking, Ranma

staying home taking care of the children.  



     "_Your_ Ranma-honey" Akane continued, "would

cut



Ranma-honey,"



class if the sky turned blue or someone told him

rain was

wet." Akane's mouth twisted slightly. "You don't

know him at



[Cut to classroom scene]



RANMA: Rain is *wet?!?* Whoa! This I gotta go see!

'Scuse me, teach!



@@^_^

Which, IMO, he would do. 



HINAKO: Hey!



<SNIP>

     Green fire crawled across her skin, burrowing

deep,

like an unseen army of insects, pricking her with

thousands of

tiny bites that drove her mad.



I like most of the description here, but "drove her

mad" seems rather vague.



@@Hmmm . . .you've got me on this one.

I'll work on it and see if I can come up with

something.



I'm open to suggestions. ^_*



 <SNIP>



in a blur, and

Ukyou was left staring stupidly at the headless

shaft of her

battle spatula. "But you see . . ." Akane got

slowly to her feet,

"I _want_ to hurt you."



Suggest: "_I_ want to hurt _you._" (this emphasis

would seem to make more sense)



@@One of the problems with ASCII.

No italic.



I was trying to reference Ukyou's

"I don't want to hurt you."



With Akane,



"I _want_ to hurt you."



Oh, well. It sounded good when I typed it. ^_^;;;;





     "I could kill you . . ." Akane _lifted_ the

taller girl free

of the ground, holding her at arm's length until

her toes

dangled inches above the path. ". . . but I'm

not." Ukyou had a



UKYO: You're not what?



Suggest: "... but I won't."



@@Good choice. Does make more sense.





     "You must have thought the 'Tunnel of Lost

Love' was

pretty funny?" Akane asked. "And when I was

possessed by

that Demon Doll?"



Um, Ukyo wasn't there for the doll story. Perhaps a

reference to "Secret Sauce"

instead, or to Ukyo and Kodachi attacking Ranma to

steal (what they thought was)

the engagement ring he was going to give to Akane.



@@^_^ She was there in the Anime. 

(The cursed doll at the Inn. Takes over Akane's body

after Ranma knocks it off the shelf chasing Genma

who has stolen his milk? (At least in the dub. Haven't

seen the sub for that one))



<SNIP>



     "You're disgusting,"Akane spat in Ukyou's

face. "Ten

                          ^^

Spacing.



years looking for vengeance and you give it up the

first time he

says you're cute? You're not samurai. You're

nothing but a

whore."



UKYO: That's a lie! Not true at all! He had to say

it TWICE!



@@LOL!!!



      "You're not samurai." she repeated. "Samurai

don't



samurai,"



give up. Samurai don't . . . don't . . ." Akane's

entire body



KUNO: [glomps Akane from behind] Oh, Akane Tendo!

Finally, you appreciate the

glorious persistence which is the true virtue of the

noble warrior!



AKANE: AAAAA! [punts him away]



@@LOL



shuddered, as if fighting an invisible current.



     *You are Samurai.* She heard her mother say.

*The



Samurai,* she



     *You are Samurai.* Again and again she'd

heard that

from her father. *You are Samurai. You must always

protect

the weak.*



SOUN: And if you happen to meet an old perverted

martial arts master, you must

always fight against him and never, ever bow down

to... why are you looking at

me like that?

 

@@<VBG>

<SNIP>

Lightning was near

kin, and bothered her no more than the city sized

tornados



city-sized tornadoes	(I think)



@@Yeah, I think you're right.



<SNIP>

      Hiroshi looked up from where he was

discussing the

differences between boys and girls with his new

girlfriend. A

charming young lady, refreshingly free of curses,

challenges or

magical artifacts.



HIROSHI: Now what was her name again? Tsubaka?

Yubasa? Something like that.



@@<VVBG> I can't decide if I'm glad I didn't think

of this myself or not. Because if I had, I might have

used it. ^_*



     Daisuke pondered this as _his_ new girl

friend, also

enchantment challenged and martially marginal

while still

being possessed of all the right parts in all the

right places,

nibbled on his ear.



suggest: 'while still possessing all the right

parts' (avoid the passive)



@@I missed this one. Thanks.



H&D are getting some? Wow, this must be an alt univ.

:)



@@<ouch> you are cruel. 



<SNIP>



I liked the chapter; the Akane-flying scene was

particularly well done; plenty

of detail and her reactions were very believable,



@@Thanks.



though I could have done

without the scientific explanations inserted by the

narrator.



@@I played with this scene for . . .oh . . .five or

seven days (including

research at the library and on-line) and this was the

best I could come

up with. You should have read some of the earlier

drafts. <groan>

NOT pretty.



(BTW, I've never left a plane at more than 3,500 feet

or so. Akane's 

reactions are _partly_ based on my _one_ malfunction,

but mostly

on reading about people who are braver than I am.)







 I'm not sure if I

have a sense of where the story is going overall;

presumably it'll be Akane

struggling to master her new power without being

mastered by it, but it'd be

nice to have more of an idea of what her main

obstacles are likely to be.



Looking forward to the next one....





Gary



@@Well, I _think_ things will be clearer with chapter

5

(four just went out) but I'm not sure.

I _thought_ things would be clearer with

Sukeban Senshi chp. 8, but my pre-readers

said no. So obviously I have no idea what's going

on. ^_!



Again, Thank you so very much for taking the 

time to C&C. It's a lot of hard work and 

I really appreciate it.















=====

"When I get a little money, I buy books;

 And, if any is left, I buy food and clothes."-Erasmus



"A man is a small thing, and the night is large 

and full of wonders." -Lord Dunsany



__________________________________________________

Do You Yahoo!?

Yahoo! Shopping - Thousands of Stores. Millions of Products.

http://shopping.yahoo.com/





-- .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List---. | Administrators - ffml-admins@fanfic.com | | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@fanfic.com | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `---http://www.fanfic.com/FFML-FAQ.txt ---'